When the necessities of life become instruments of profit, the freedom to choose becomes a privilege of those who can afford it.
We are told that we are free to choose. Where to live, where to work, what to buy, and who to do business with. We celebrate the freedom of the market and the opportunities it creates. We regard the ability to build wealth through enterprise and investment as a fundamental feature of our economic system.
But how much of that freedom is real when the choices available to us are all variations of the same obligation to pay?
We cannot simply choose not to have shelter, food, utilities, or transportation. Increasingly, we cannot meaningfully participate in society without internet access and a cellphone. These are not inherent human necessities. We have made them necessities by building our institutions, businesses, and daily lives around them. Employment, education, banking, healthcare, and government services increasingly presume that we possess and pay for the means to access them.
These developments brought extraordinary benefits. They also created new dependencies.
A necessity does not have to be natural to become unavoidable.
Nor can we simply withdraw from these arrangements. Even the desire to live independently from modern society requires substantial resources. Land must be purchased or lawfully accessed, taxes paid, regulations followed, and the means of survival acquired. Many of these requirements serve legitimate public purposes, protecting the rights, safety, and interests of others. But they also mean that leaving the systems upon which we depend carries an enormous price.
We are not free to opt out of society without paying an exit fee. Most of us cannot afford the admission price to an alternative.
This brings us to a distinction that is too often lost in our conversations about the economy.
Value creation and wealth extraction are not the same economic activity.
A business that produces something useful, provides a valuable service, develops new technology, or improves efficiency can create wealth by making life better. Its success can benefit workers, customers, investors, and the wider community.
But wealth can also be accumulated by controlling access to something people already need. A company can increase its revenue without improving its product, expanding its service, or creating anything new. It may simply possess the power to demand more from those who have few alternatives.
Profit alone tells us very little about which of these activities is taking place.
Consider housing. A landlord who builds, maintains, and improves homes provides something of value. The investment, work, and risk involved deserve compensation.
But what happens when the pressure to maximize returns overwhelms the obligation to provide housing at a price people can afford?
The Department of Justice's case against RealPage illustrates how far this problem can extend. Federal authorities alleged that rental pricing software used competitively sensitive, nonpublic information from competing landlords to recommend prices, discourage reductions, and diminish competition. A proposed federal settlement in 2025 sought to restrict those practices.
The allegations reveal a disturbing possibility: competing businesses can appear independent while relying on common systems that undermine the very competition supposed to protect consumers.
A market does not become competitive merely because more than one company is collecting the payments.
And when the product is shelter, the consequences are not merely commercial. The person on the receiving end cannot simply decide that housing is no longer worth the price.
These relationships exist throughout our economy in different forms. Essential infrastructure, utilities, healthcare, communications, and housing all create opportunities for private enterprise. They also create opportunities for concentrated economic power to exploit dependency.
Not every profit earned from a necessity is exploitation. Investment, innovation, maintenance, and reliable service all require resources and deserve returns. But when the ability to extract payment becomes more valuable than the work of creating value, the economy begins rewarding control over contribution.
The accumulated consequences can be enormous.
A 2025 RAND working paper estimated that, between 1975 and 2023, the bottom 90 percent of American workers received approximately $79 trillion less in cumulative income than they would have if economic growth had been more evenly distributed. That figure is a comparison with a hypothetical distribution, not a ledger of money directly taken from individual workers. It nevertheless illustrates the extraordinary scale of the growing divide in who benefits from our collective economic progress.
This is the dynamic I have previously described as Vacuum Economics. Wealth concentrates, and that concentration creates additional opportunities to acquire assets, control markets, and claim a greater portion of the income generated by everyone else's work. The wealth need not sit idle to be removed from ordinary people's reach. It can remain actively invested, accumulating ownership and influence over the systems upon which the rest of society depends.
The machinery does not have to be deliberately malicious to produce these outcomes. Some arrangements emerged from innovation and convenience. Others reflect outdated institutions, regulatory failures, or deliberate efforts to capture markets and eliminate competition.
Their origins differ. Their consequences accumulate.
And this brings us to the question of government.
We have long understood that government must be restrained from abusing its authority over the people. We establish rights, divide powers, and create institutions intended to prevent those entrusted with authority from turning it against the public.
But private institutions can also exercise enormous power over people's lives, particularly when they control access to the things society has made essential.
Government must protect the public from abuses of concentrated power, whether that power is governmental or economic.
This does not require government to own every business, set every price, or extinguish the legitimate rewards of enterprise. It requires public institutions capable of enforcing competition, regulating essential services, protecting consumers, and ensuring that meaningful alternatives remain available.
Sometimes that means preventing monopolistic practices. Sometimes it means public investment, utility oversight, or publicly available alternatives. It always means recognizing that the economic security of ordinary people is a legitimate public interest.
Government serves the entire public, including businesses, investors, workers, and consumers. But equal concern for their rights does not mean ignoring the enormous differences in their power.
Those who possess concentrated wealth already have substantial means to defend their interests. Those whose next paycheck determines whether they can afford shelter or medicine have considerably fewer.
Public responsibility must account for that imbalance.
We cannot reasonably promise freedom while permitting the necessities of ordinary life to become instruments of unchecked economic power. Nor can we indefinitely sustain an economy that rewards those who control access to society more generously than those whose work sustains it.
The price of society should be what we contribute to sustaining it, not whatever those who control its necessities can compel us to pay.
We have built this society together. Its benefits should not belong primarily to those who can afford to own the gates.